I just finished watching a TEDx Talk by Mr Rush Doshi. I, however, have a few differences in opinion, and since it has been five years and one month since the talk, I do wonder if his views have changed on the issues. My first disagreement is with his generalisation implying similar cultural evolution of India and China, which is not the case. Secondly, only 40% of population in India is dependent on Himalayan waters. Productivity per capita in China US, and India, has not shown any sign of convergence to a same or similar value, not in 2014, not today.